Key Takeaways
- According to Cox Automotive, average dealer service and parts revenue reached $9.23M in 2025, yet dealer share of service visits fell from 33% to 29% over eight years, meaning more vehicles are being serviced at independent shops.
- Only 54% of new car owners returned to a dealership for service in 2025, according to CBT News, creating a growing pool of vehicle owners actively looking for a shop they can trust.
- IMR Automotive Market Research identifies incentivizing customer return as one of the top four challenges for repair shops in 2025, meaning the shops that build loyalty now will be the ones that outlast the competition.
Dealership service departments are generating more revenue than ever, yet they are losing the customer count that makes that revenue sustainable. According to Cox Automotive 2025, average dealer service and parts revenue reached approximately $9.23 million per location in 2025, up 33% over eight years, even as dealer share of service visits fell from 33% to 29%. Those departing customers are going somewhere. For well-positioned independent repair shops, that somewhere can be your bay.
Where Are the Customers Going When They Leave Dealerships?
The short answer: general repair shops. According to Cox Automotive 2025, the drift is specifically toward general repair, not quick-lube chains or specialty shops. That distinction matters. General repair shops are competing for exactly the kind of multi-visit, ongoing maintenance customer that dealerships are failing to retain.
The scale of defection is notable. According to CBT News 2025, only 54% of new car owners returned to a dealership for service in 2025. That means nearly half of new car buyers are already looking elsewhere after their first service experience. As vehicles age out of warranty coverage, that number only accelerates. Older vehicles equal fewer reasons to return to the dealer, and those owners represent steady, repeatable repair business for independent shops.
For more on how independent shops are gaining ground in this shift, see Independent Shops Lead Dealerships in Service Preference Shift.
Why Is Dealership Service Loyalty Dropping So Fast?
Price is part of it, but not the whole story. According to Automotive News 2025, service retention is described as the key to dealership profitability, which tells you exactly how worried dealers are about losing it. The fact that they are losing it despite record revenue suggests the problem is not demand, it is experience and trust.
Customers leaving dealerships often cite inconvenience, long wait times, and difficulty communicating with service advisors. Independent shops that answer the phone promptly, explain work clearly, and follow up after the job have a structural advantage here. The dealership service department is built around volume and upsell. The independent shop can be built around the customer.
That said, independent shops have their own retention problem to manage. According to IMR Automotive Market Research 2025, incentivizing customer return ranks as one of the top four concerns for repair shops, alongside finding affordable parts and managing overhead. Capturing a customer from a dealership is step one. Keeping them is the harder part.
What Do Independent Shops Need to Actually Capture These Customers?
Three things stand out from the data: visibility, trust signals, and a reason to come back.
Visibility means showing up when someone searches for a shop after their warranty expires or after a frustrating dealer experience. Most of those searches happen on a phone, close to home, and the shops that appear in the map pack with strong ratings get the call. A Google Business Profile with recent reviews, accurate hours, and photos of your actual shop is not optional infrastructure at this point. It is your first impression for a customer who has never heard of you.
Trust signals matter because customers leaving dealerships are not abandoning quality, they are abandoning hassle. They still want confidence that the shop knows what it is doing. Online reviews are the primary way a first-time customer assesses that before picking up the phone. Volume, recency, and how you respond to negative feedback all factor into that judgment.
And then there is the return visit. According to IMR Automotive Market Research 2025, getting customers back for the next service is a documented challenge across the industry. Shops that build a follow-up process, whether that is a reminder when an oil change is due, a text after a repair, or a loyalty program for repeat visits, are the ones that convert a one-time defector from the dealership into a long-term customer.
For a closer look at how trust and review data affect which shop a driver calls, see Auto Repair Shop Trust Gap: Reviews and Customer Conversion.
Why This Matters for Auto Repair Shops
The market is moving toward independent shops whether the industry planned for it or not. According to Cox Automotive 2025, that share shift has been consistent over eight years and shows no sign of reversing. The vehicles on the road are getting older, warranties are expiring, and drivers who had a poor dealer experience are actively looking for an alternative they can trust.
The opportunity is real, but it is not automatic. Shops that are hard to find online, slow to respond, or thin on reviews will not capture these customers just because dealer share is declining. The customers will go to whoever looks most credible and accessible when they search. The shops building that profile now are the ones positioned to grow as the dealer market continues to contract.
The practical move is straightforward: audit what a first-time customer sees when they search for your shop. Check your Google Business Profile for accuracy, look at your review count and when the last one came in, and make sure your phone is answered or returned promptly. The customers are out there looking. The question is whether they find you.
Sources